Buttery Roasted Pistachio Toffee

Bay Area Crafted, Small-Batch Pistachio Toffee

Elevate your snack game with our Artisanal Pistachio Toffee. We’ve taken the classic buttery crunch of our signature toffee and paired it with the deep, earthy flavor of slow-roasted pistachios. Each batch is hand-poured and finished with a velvety chocolate layer, creating a sophisticated treat that is as beautiful as it is delicious.
Proudly made in San Mateo County, our Pistachio Toffee is a popular choice for those seeking high-end, local artisan sweets. It’s a standout on charcuterie boards and pairs beautifully with a glass of California Cabernet.
**Flavor Profile:** Toasted nuttiness with a rich caramel finish.
**Local Availability:** Hand-delivered to select Bay Area retail partners for peak freshness. Also available at farmers markets and festivals, or order directly using the button below.

Order Now

Pistachio Toffee for Gifting & Everyday Indulgences

Open gift box containing a package of sugar butter love toffee, a small jar of fig and walnut spread, a box of dried apricots, a bottle of Moët & Chandon champagne, a small round tin of barard chocolate, and a small spoon.

Luxury Corporate Gifts

A great choice for your VIP clients. The vibrant green pistachios offer a premium look and gourmet taste that complements any gift box.

A round dining table set for six guests with white and gold ornamental plates, silverware, and six tall champagne flutes filled with sparkling wine. In the center, there is a large floral arrangement with white and blush pink flowers and green foliage. Small paper bags labeled ‘sugar-butter-love’ containing butternutronch toffee are placed at each seat, tied with a small string and a sprig of eucalyptus.

Elegant Wedding & Event Favors

Bring a local touch to your San Mateo County celebrations, autumn wedding, or upscale dinner parties.

A woman relaxing in a bubble bath with lit candles, a glass of red wine, and a package of granola on a wooden tray, enjoying a snack.

The Connoisseur’s Indulgence

A refined treat for your own secret stash. Perfectly pairs with a morning espresso or a glass of evening wine.

A tidy office desk with a computer, potted plant, coffee mug, notebook, pens, and a bag of sugar-butter-love toffee with almonds, some pieces of toffee in a bowl, and a laptop screen displaying business software.

Boutique & Special Presents

The perfect standalone gift for the foodies and artisan-lovers in your life who appreciate a sophisticated twist on a classic confection.

What Customers Are Saying

"Nicole sent me some of the toffee bites you made and I have to say they are absolutely delicious!"

— Bill
"Holy crap, this stuff is delicious!"

— Danielle
"We love your toffee! YUMMY. Great for gifts, thank you's, special recognition's. Thank you, sugar∙butter∙love."

-Joy

FAQs About Our Pistachio Toffee

How long does your pistachio toffee last?

Our products are best enjoyed within a few weeks of purchase, although many customers say they disappear much faster than that!

What is the difference between your toffee flavors?

Each flavor has its own personality! Pistachio toffee has a rich nutty flavor, almond is the classic butter flavor, and the sea salt combines sweet and salty.

Does your pistachio toffee require refrigeration?

No, please do not refrigerate it! Our pistachio toffee is a shelf-stable confection. Once opened, keep it sealed tightly in an airtight container to protect it from humidity.

Is your pistachio toffee safe for individuals with peanut or other tree nut allergies?

While our star ingredient is the pistachio (a tree nut), we take allergy safety very seriously. Our pistachio toffee is produced in a facility that also handles peanuts, almonds, and dairy products, so we recommend exercising caution.

Find Us Locally

Craving sugar.butter.love Pistachio Toffee?
Find it at Bay Area shops, markets, and fairs.

Store Locator

View Markets & Fairs