Soft Peanut Butter Brittle

A Softer Take on a Classic Favorite

Forget everything you know about hard, tooth-breaking brittle. Our Soft Peanut Butter Brittle is a total game-changer. Inspired by a family recipe and perfected in our San Mateo cottage kitchen, this brittle features a light, aerated texture that literally melts on your tongue.

With its savory-sweet flavor and distinctive bite, it has become a customer favorite. It’s the “un-brittle” brittle that keeps customers coming back. Taste the difference of small-batch, handmade care.

  • Texture: Light, flaky, and easy to bite.

  • Why It’s Unique: A softer alternative to traditional brittle—perfect for all ages.

Order Now

How to Enjoy Our Melt-In-Your-Mouth Peanut Brittle

Camping scene with tents in a forest near a lake, showing trail mix, granola bar, and a water bottle on a rock in the foreground.

Campfire Treat

Pack a bag for your next camping trip. It’s the ultimate elevate-your-s'mores ingredient or a high-energy, sweet reward after a long day on the trail.

Snack spread on a wooden table featuring a bag of sugar-butter-love toffee with almonds, bowls of popcorn, gummy bears, and almonds, along with bottles of soda, a book, and a TV showing a black-and-white movie in a cozy living room setting.

Cozy Movie Nights

Upgrade your standard popcorn routine. Crushing this handmade toffee over warm, buttery popcorn creates the ultimate gourmet sweet-and-savory movie snack.

A straw beach bag filled with towels, sunglasses, a book, a wrapped snack, a water bottle, and a packet of allergy medication, placed on sandy beach with umbrellas and people in the background.

Sunny Beach Days

Bring a sweet treat to the coast. Whether you’re relaxing at Half Moon Bay or catching a coastal breeze, these small-batch bags are the perfect easy-to-share beach bite.

A picnic setup outdoors with a wicker basket, a package of sugar-butter-love toffee, a jar of jam, a cheese plate with grapes and cheese slices, and small jars of green olives on a blue and white checkered blanket, with a straw hat and trees in the background.

Local Picnic Baskets

The perfect dessert to pack for an afternoon at your favorite San Mateo County park. It travels easily, doesn't melt instantly like standard chocolate, and pairs beautifully with fruit.

What Customers Are Saying

  • "The soft peanut butter brittle is magic in your mouth!"

    -Kim

  • "The Soft Peanut Butter Brittle takes the world by storm…in other words, it’s delicious!"

    — Tom

  • "Holy crap, this stuff is delicious!"

    — Danielle

Read More Reviews

FAQs About Our Soft Peanut Brittle

How long does your Peanut Brittle last?

Our brittle is shelf-stable and typically lasts 1-2 months if stored in an air container at room temperature.

Is your brittle hard or soft?

Our peanut butter brittle has a softer, easier-to-bite texture compared to traditional brittle.

Do you offer corporate gifting, bulk ordering, or custom event packaging?

Yes, we love helping you sweeten your events! Our Soft Peanut Butter Brittle is one of our most popular items for corporate holiday gifts, wedding favors, and family reunions because it's a nostalgic treat that absolutely everyone can easily chew and enjoy.

How can I use this brittle besides just eating it straight from the bag?

While it is incredibly addicting on its own, its delicate, melt-away texture makes it an amazing culinary ingredient. You can use it as an ice Cream topper or sprinkle it over your morning yogurt parfait for a salty-sweet protein boost.

Find Us Locally

To get your hands on a fresh bag of sugar.butter.love Peanut Butter Brittle, check out our trusted Bay Area retail partners who stock our treats, or come say hello in person at our next local farmers market or fair!

Store Locator
View Markets & Fairs